Hmm, interesting views. As my name implies, I'm just a newbie when it comes to investing, but in a lot of my research there's talk about money to be made in the stocks during a downturn. As the mathematics and logistics of it all is way beyond my comprehension (I will NEVER understand the concept of "split stocks"), one thing that captured my understanding was the term "Dogs of the Dow". As you both seem to be well versed in the stocks and finance, I'm sure I don't have to define this term, but it's the way I've chosen to go so far and I've made a good ROI despite my friends losing massive amounts on higher risk stocks (except for the one that invested in google when it was valued below $300/per, oh how I wish I'd done that).
Anyway, my point is that though I agree it is wrong to be overly optimistic about today's market, I also feel that it is wrong to veer towards the other extreme of being overly pessimistic. Yes, banks are facing hard times regarding real estate and bad debts, but a lot of financial institutions still have staples in other areas that bring them plenty of revenue and inflate their capital. Not to mention there are PLENTY of businesses finding innovative ways to capitalize on this recession.
I could be way off course and completely wrong, but end of the day the game still seems the same; you have to do your homework and invest based on your risk preference, time, and confidence in your research.